Why? One can test and fix laptops without the OEM charger, most of the time. If they bring it, sure, check to be sure it is outputting 19v.
Several reasons:
1. Make sure the charger is good.
2. Make sure it's the correct voltage/amperage
3. Make sure it has no bent or missing sense pin that could damage a new port we install.
We used to do like you and never required a charger. We changed our policy after getting a few negative reviews that could have been avoided if we had the charger.
The straw that broke the camel's back was repairing an HP, typical busted jack and shorted protection diode. The customer took it home and called up, screaming that they had paid $150 and that we hadn't fixed the problem. I asked them to bring it back with the charger, and sure enough, the pin smashed sideways and busted the new jack we installed. We replaced the jack pro-bono, sold them an HP charger, and for our troubles? We got a negative review saying we charged $150 on a laptop repair when it only needed a charger (according to the customer). The customer's wife deduced that since it didn't charge after our repair, charged after we replaced the charger, that's all it needed. All the rest of our work was unnecessary and nothing we said would change their mind. We are a rip-off shop taking advantage of people.
We're blessed with an abundance of work all the time; if we get slow, we might change our policy, but we've avoided a few times similar problems. Gaming laptops with underrated aftermarket chargers, customers buy AM chargers, reversing the polarity, or selecting the wrong voltage. Just better for us to make sure we're giving them back something without issues.